Home / News / Your guide to the bitter AGL demerger 

Your guide to the bitter AGL demerger 

For the moment, AGL is in limbo. Possibly we will see a return to the corporate tussles of the 1980s.
News

It’s not quite a 1980’s style corporate raider attempt, but it’s pretty darn close. Australia’s 4th richest man is trying to disrupt the dissembling of the country’s largest energy generator and retailer. After previously trying to buy the whole company twice, MikeCannonBrookes, through his holding company Grok Ventures, has effectively secured 11% of AGLEnergyLimited (ASX: AGL) with a complex set of derivatives. He aims to vote against the proposed demerger (he even dedicated a website to it) scheduled for June 15, resulting in the separation of AGL’s retail and legacy generation business.

Source: Update on AGL Demerger June 2021

With the demerger requiring 75% of shareholders to vote in favour to be approved – and not all shareholders choosing to vote – MCB has become a very prickly thorn in the side of the AGL board.

The board argues that a demerger is the best way to unlock value from the company. To understand why we need to rewind. Historically, vertically integrated energy businesses (known as gentailers) like AGL have used energy generated from their extensive coal and gas assets as baseload power for their customer base. Since it was all under one umbrella, AGL could hold onto wholesale margin, secure supply and compete better for customers.

  • Then renewables began to disrupt the status quo. The growth of rooftop solar and wind meant energy prices can go negative during the day when supply is abundant, making legacy energy generation loss-making (paying customers to take energy). This shift has been coming for the better part of a decade. But management failed to act and position the company accordingly. As a result, the AGL share price is down 70% over the past five years and the board is trying to split it in two to capture what little value is left.

    The retail division is a decent company that will attract investors on its own. It’s not dissimilar from Telstra Corporation Ltd (ASX: TLS), given it’s the number one energy utility retailer with some decent renewable assets. But the pain point is Accel Energy. It owns a stable of assets that are no longer particularly attractive and need redevelopment. Most banks are unwilling to lend to fossil fuel companies, increasing the cost of capital. On its own, investors take significant operational risk, evident by the recent closing of Loy Yang A Unit 2 until August. Plus investors have to trust AGL to develop ‘energy hubs’, something the business has little expertise in.

    Historically, MCB has been a public beacon for greater action on climate change. He wants AGL to shut down its coal plants quickly, and transition to renewable energy faster. It’s not yet apparent why he couldn’t just do that with Accel Energy demerged. Possibly he hopes to keep the gentailer model where energy generation is used to support retail demand, therefore, bringing emissions down sooner. Keeping the two together would make sense financially. Earnings from the retail division could be used to fund the redevelopment of the generation business.

    While this all sounds noble, the primary issue is that MCB has no detailed plan. Well, he hasn’t shared one pubicly. It’s easy to throw stones, but proxy advisors and institutions can’t be expected to vote against a demerger that at least in the short term could provide some level of shareholder accretion. The complex series of derivatives he owns the 11% stake also makes investors nervous. What if he decides overnight to dump his holding? Hence the dilemma facing shareholders.

    Do you take a punt on a billionaire without a concrete plan? Or do you trust the incumbent board that has destroyed shareholder value and owns just 0.012% of the company themselves? It’s not a very enviable position to be in. Although if MCB can develop a credible alternative before the demerger date, there is enough support and goodwill to suggest he could get it over the line, or at least force the AGL board to reconsider.

    The best outcome for suffering AGL shareholders is that MCB and the board come to the table and thrash out a plan. With the MCB tick of approval, it will give shareholders faith the AGL board has a credible path forward and is aligned with investor interests. However, given both party’s reluctance to engage constructively this seems unlikely. Add in the fact the board needs 84% of the remaining votes means the demerger already looks dead in the water.

    For the moment, AGL is in limbo. Possibly we will see a return to the corporate tussles of the 1980s.

    Information warning: The information in this article was published by The Rask Group Pty Ltd (ABN: 36 622 810 995) is limited to factual information or (at most) general financial advice only. That means, the information and advice does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. It is not specific to you, your needs, goals or objectives. Because of that, you should consider if the advice is appropriate to you and your needs, before acting on the information. If you don’t know what your needs are, you should consult a trusted and licensed financial adviser who can provide you with personal financial product advice. In addition, you should obtain and read the product disclosure statement (PDS) before making a decision to acquire a financial product. Please read our Terms and Conditions and Financial Services Guide before using this website. The Rask Group Pty Ltd is a Corporate Authorised Representative (#1280930) of AFSL #383169




    Print Article

    Related
    Why bank analysts prefer this quality lender over the rest

    Morgans have released a summary of the key points from the recent bank reporting season. Of the banks that reported, Morgans says NAB was in line with consensus expectations, while ANZ and WBC beat consensus earnings expectations. Despite this, Morgans holds NAB as having the strongest 1H22 performance overall. NAB produced the strongest profit growth…

    Ishan Dan | 18th May 2022 | More
    Two of the most bullish bets on the ASX

    Markets around the world are still in freefall as losses mount as a result of investors moving out of risk partly due to inflation fears and supply chain disruptions partly due to the crisis in Ukraine and Covid lockdowns in China. The market is yet to become comfortable with the rate hike cycle that is…

    Ishan Dan | 18th May 2022 | More
    Top of the pops – top global funds had one thing in common

    March stands out as being one of the most difficult periods for investors in a generation. On the one hand, bond markets send fixed income to its worst return in more decades, and on the other, equity markets were sold off broadly on valuation concerns as bond yields ended a forty-year downward trend. It is…

    Drew Meredith | 18th May 2022 | More
    Popular
    1
    What does High Conviction mean?
    Ishan Dan | 10th Mar 2021 | More
    2
    Inside CSL’s big end of year deal
    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 15th Dec 2021 | More
    3
    Battery materials in short supply but valuation is key
    Ishan Dan | 25th Mar 2022 | More
    4
    Behind Brickworks’ (ASX:BKW) record profit
    Jaz Harrison | 25th Mar 2022 | More
    5
    Is JB Hi-Fi the best retailer in Australia?
    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 25th Mar 2022 | More
    6
    Three ASX stocks ripe for a takeover
    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 23rd Mar 2022 | More