Home / News / Are you one of the million people holding a dud fund?

Are you one of the million people holding a dud fund?


As part of the Government’s ‘Your Future, Your Super’ (YFYS) reforms, all APRA regulated super funds will be submitted to a performance test on a yearly basis. The test has been derided by the industry but ultimately forces every fund to measure itself against the index or ‘average’ fund. Where is persistently underperforms it will be forced to contact members and if this continues, ultimately stop accepting new members.

On APRA’s first run, thirteen MySuper products have failed the APRA performance test.

What that means is that one million Australians are tied to underperforming default super funds. The funds will be forced to send a letter to the 1.1m members by the end of September encouraging them switch to a better fund.

  • In total, APRA looked at 76 MySuper products and assessed them against 5 years of performance history against a benchmark. They were graded as a ‘Pass’ or ‘Fail’. Some of the largest funds that did not pass are included in this list:

    These include:

    1. AMG MySuper
    2. Commonwealth Bank Group Super
    3. Energy Industries Superannuation Scheme-Pool
    4. Colonial First State FirstChoice Superannuation Trust
    5. Labour Union Co-Operative Retirement Fund
    6. Maritime Super
    7. BT Super’s Retirement Wrap
    8. ASGARD Independence Plan Division Two
    9. Australian Catholic Superannuation and Retirement Fund
    10. The Victorian Independent Schools Superannuation Fund
    11. Boc Gases Superannuation Fund
    12. AvSuper Fund
    13. Christian Super

    On the other hand +80 per cent of default super funds passed the test with flying colours. The top 10 performers by net return, assume a 30 year old with a $50k balance were:

    1. Active Super 9.46%
    2. AustralianSuper 9.44%
    3. HOSTPLUS Superannuation Fund%
    4. AON Master Trust 9.14%
    5. Goldman Sachs & JBWere Superannuation Fund 9.13%
    6. Unisuper 9.01%
    7. Construction and Building Unions Superannuation Fund 9%
    8. Mine Superannuation Fund 8.86%
    9. QSuper Lifetime 8.8%
    10. Retirement Wrap Westpac Group 8.75%

    Trustees of the failed products have an important choice of either making the improvements required to pass next year’s test or to transfer members funds to a fund that can deliver better return. APRA has also requested that these managed funds provide a report identifying the causes of their underperformance and how they plan to address them.

    The flipside to this coin, is this test doesn’t take into account risk, lifecycle, or environmental, social and governance (ESG) screening considerations. Good products such as a value-based fund, may fail this test because of their investment style life cycle.

    Trustees of failed products are required to write to members by 27 September 2021.

    Print Article

    Two ends of the spectrum, as Metcash beats and Carsales buys

    Negative news on the economy eventually becomes good news for stocks, as markets rally on hopes that rate hikes may not be as aggressive as expected. Tech and consumer retailers have gained more than 2 per cent with the healthcare sector the “worst,” adding just 0.8 per cent in the last few trading sessions. In…

    Ishan Dan | 29th Jun 2022 | More
    What is really in the S&P/ASX 200 Index?

    The S&P/ASX 200 Index, often referred to as the ASX 200, is considered to be one of the benchmark Australian indexes. It forms the basis of the fourth and fifth most popular exchange-traded funds on the market and is commonly used by fund managers to measure their relative performance. Most will know what the index…

    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 29th Jun 2022 | More
    What to watch for in portfolios amid a year of change

    The latter half of 2021 and the majority of 2022 have been among the most challenging periods for investors in several decades. The traditional balanced portfolio, defined as one that holds 40 per cent of assets in government bonds and 60 per cent in indexed equities, is on track for the sixth-worst beginnings to a…

    Drew Meredith | 29th Jun 2022 | More
    What does High Conviction mean?
    Ishan Dan | 10th Mar 2021 | More
    Three ASX stocks ripe for a takeover
    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 23rd Mar 2022 | More
    Battery materials in short supply but valuation is key
    Ishan Dan | 25th Mar 2022 | More
    Behind Brickworks’ (ASX:BKW) record profit
    Jaz Harrison | 25th Mar 2022 | More
    Is JB Hi-Fi the best retailer in Australia?
    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 25th Mar 2022 | More
    Inside CSL’s big end of year deal
    Lachlan Buur-Jensen | 15th Dec 2021 | More